Comment on "Isolating Polaritonic 2D-IR Transmission Spectra".

This Viewpoint responds to the analysis of 2D IR spectra of vibration cavity polaritons in the study reported in The Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters (Duan et al. 2021, 12, 11406). That report analyzed 2D IR spectra of strongly coupled molecules, such as W(CO)6 and nitroprusside anion, based on subtracting a background signal generated by polariton filtered free space signals. They assigned the resulting response as being due to excited polaritons. We point out in this Viewpoint that virtually all of the response can be properly reproduced using the physics of transmission through an etalon containing a material modeled with a complex dielectric function describing the ground- and excited-state absorber populations. Furthermore, such a coupled system cannot be described as a scaled sum of the bare molecular and cavity responses.

Extremophilic behavior of catalytic amyloids sustained by backbone structuring.

Enzyme function relies on the placement of chemistry defined by solvent and self-associative hydrogen bonding displayed by the protein backbone. Amyloids, long-range multi-peptide and -protein materials, can mimic enzyme functions while having a high proportion of stable self-associative backbone hydrogen bonds. Though catalytic amyloid structures have exhibited a degree of temperature and solvent stability, defining their full extremophilic properties and the molecular basis for such extreme activity has yet to be realized. Here we demonstrate that, like thermophilic enzymes, catalytic amyloid activity persists across high temperatures with an optimum activity at 81 °C where they are 30-fold more active than at room temperature. Unlike thermophilic enzymes, catalytic amyloids retain both activity and structure well above 100 °C as well as in the presence of co-solvents. Changes in backbone vibrational states are resolved in situ using non-linear 2D infrared spectroscopy (2DIR) to reveal that activity is sustained by reorganized backbone hydrogen bonds in extreme environments, evidenced by an emergent vibrational mode centered at 1612 cm-1. Restructuring also occurs in organic solvents, and facilitates complete retention of hydrolysis activity in co-solvents of lesser polarity. We support these findings with molecular modeling, where the displacement of water by co-solvents leads to shorter, less competitive, bonding lifetimes that further stabilize self-associative backbone interactions. Our work defines amyloid properties that counter classical proteins, where extreme environments induce mechanisms of restructuring to support enzyme-like functions necessary for synthetic applications.

Comparative analysis of polaritons in bulk, dielectric slabs, and planar cavities with implications for cavity-modified reactivity.

We examine closely the differences between the densities of vibrational states of bulk, slab, and cavity polariton modes under weak and moderate inhomogeneous broadening. While existing theoretical treatments are often based on a comparative analysis of "bare" vibrations and cavity polaritons, in the strong-coupling regime, only differences between slab/bulk polaritons on the one hand and cavity polaritons on the other hand are meaningful since "bare" vibrations are not observed experimentally. We find that polaritons in cavities significantly detuned from resonance with molecular transitions at zero in-plane wavevector do not differ appreciably from bulk polaritons in their density of vibrational states. Only cavity polaritons with sufficiently weak inhomogeneous broadening and tuned to resonance near normal incidence display a pronounced density-of-state enhancement. These results shed light on the heretofore puzzling observations of modified chemical reactivity only at zero detuning and supply a new baseline for assessing the explanatory power of proposed theories of cavity-modified chemistry.

Vibration-Cavity Polariton Chemistry and Dynamics.

Molecular polaritons result from light-matter coupling between optical resonances and molecular electronic or vibrational transitions. When the coupling is strong enough, new hybridized states with mixed photon-material character are observed spectroscopically, with resonances shifted above and below the uncoupled frequency. These new modes have unique optical properties and can be exploited to promote or inhibit physical and chemical processes. One remarkable result is that vibrational strong coupling to cavities can alter reaction rates and product branching ratios with no optical excitation whatsoever. In this work we review the ability of vibration-cavity polaritons to modify chemical and physical processes including chemical reactivity, as well as steady-state and transient spectroscopy. We discuss the larger context of these works and highlight their most important contributions and implications. Our goal is to provide insight for systematically manipulating molecular polaritons in photonic and chemical applications.

Hyperbolic phonon polariton resonances in calcite nanopillars.

We report the first experimental observation of hyperbolic phonon polariton (HP) resonances in calcite nanopillars, demonstrate that the HP modes redshift with increasing aspect ratio (AR = 0.5 to 1.1), observe a new, possibly higher order mode as the pitch is reduced, and compare the results to both numerical simulations and an analytical model. This work shows that a wide variety of polar dielectric materials can support phonon polaritons by demonstrating HPs in a new material, which is an important first step towards creating a library of materials with the appropriate phonon properties to extend phonon polariton applications throughout the infrared.

Excited-state vibration-polariton transitions and dynamics in nitroprusside.

Strong cavity coupling to molecular vibrations creates vibration-polaritons capable of modifying chemical reaction kinetics, product branching ratios, and charge transfer equilibria. However, the mechanisms impacting these molecular processes remain elusive. Furthermore, even basic elements determining the spectral properties of polaritons, such as selection rules, transition moments, and lifetimes are poorly understood. Here, we use two-dimensional infrared and filtered pump-probe spectroscopy to report clear spectroscopic signatures and relaxation dynamics of excited vibration-polaritons formed from the cavity-coupled NO band of nitroprusside. We apply an extended multi-level quantum Rabi model that predicts transition frequencies and strengths that agree well with our experiment. Notably, the polariton features decay ~3-4 times slower than the polariton dephasing time, indicating that they support incoherent population, a consequence of their partial matter character.

Power of Aerogel Platforms to Explore Mesoscale Transport in Catalysis.

We describe the opportunity to deploy aerogels-an ultraporous nanoarchitecture with co-continuous networks of meso/macropores and covalently bonded nanoparticulates-as a platform to address the nature of the electronic, ionic, and mass transport that underlies catalytic activity. As a test case, we fabricated Au||TiO2 junctions in composite guest-host aerogels in which ∼5 nm Au nanoparticles are incorporated either directly into the anatase TiO2 network (Au "in" TiO2, AuIN-TiO2 aerogel) or deposited onto preformed TiO2 aerogel (Au "on" TiO2, AuON/TiO2 aerogel). The metal-meets-oxide nanoscale interphase as visualized by electron tomography feature extended three-dimensional (3D) interfaces, but AuIN-TiO2 aerogels impose a greater degree of Au contact with TiO2 particles than does the AuON/TiO2 form. Both aerogel variants enable transport of electrons over micrometer-scale distances across the TiO2 network to Au||TiO2 junctions, as evidenced by electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) and ultrafast visible pump-IR probe time-resolved absorption spectroscopy. The siting of gold nanoparticles in the TiO2 network more effectively disperses trapped electrons. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations find that increased physical contact between Au and TiO2, induced by oxygen vacancies, produces increased hybridization of midgap states and quenches unpaired trapped electrons. We assign the apparent differences in electron-transport capabilities to a combination of the relatively better-wired Au||TiO2 junctions in AuIN-TiO2 aerogels, which have a greater capacity to dilute accumulated charge over a larger interfacial surface area, with an enhanced ability to discharge the accumulated electrons via catalytic reduction of adsorbed O2 to O2- at the interface. Solid-state 1H nuclear magnetic resonance experiments show that proton spin-lattice relaxation times and possibly proton diffusion are strongly coupled to Au||TiO2 interfacial design, likely through spin coupling of protons to unpaired electrons trapped at the TiO2 network. Taken together, our results show that Au||TiO2 interfacial design strongly impacts charge carrier (electron and proton) transport over mesoscale distances in catalytic aerogel architectures.

Negligible Effect of Vibrational Polaritons on Chemical Reaction Rates via the Density of States Pathway.

We show that the polariton density of states in planar optical cavities strongly coupled to vibrational excitations remains much lower than the density of vibrational states even at the frequency of the lower and upper polaritons under most practical circumstances. The polariton density of states is higher within a narrow window only when the inhomogeneous line width is at least an order of magnitude smaller than the Rabi splitting. Therefore, modification of reaction rates via the density-of-states pathway appears small or negligible for the scenarios reported in the literature. While the polariton density of states is bounded from above by the free-space optical density of states in dielectric cavities, it can be much higher for localized phonon polariton modes of nanoscale particles. We conclude that other potential explanations of the reported reactivity changes under vibrational strong coupling should be examined.

Nanosecond transient absorption studies of the pH-dependent hydrated electron quenching by HSO3.

The large standard reduction potential of an aqueous solvated electron (eaq-, E° = -2.9 V) makes it an attractive candidate for reductive treatment of wastewater contaminants. Using transient absorption spectroscopy, the nanosecond to microsecond dynamics of eaq- generated from 10 mM solutions of Na2SO3 at pH 4 to 11 in H2O and D2O are characterized, resulting in the determination that between pH 4 and 9 it is the HSO3-, and not H+ as previously postulated by others, that effectively quenches eaq-. The observed bimolecular quenching rate constant (k = 1.2 × 108 M-1 s-1) for eaq- deactivation by HSO3- is found to be consistent with a Brønsted acid catalysis mechanism resulting in formation of H˙ and SO32-. A large solvent isotope effect is observed from the lifetimes of the eaq- in H2O compared to D2O (kH2O/kD2O = 4.4). In addition, the bimolecular rate constant for eaq- deactivation by DSO3- (k = 2.7 × 107 M-1 s-1) is found to be an order of magnitude lower than by HSO3-. These results highlight the role of acids, such as HSO3-, in competition with organic contaminant targets for eaq- and, by extension, that knowledge of the pKa of eaq- sources can be a predictive measure of the effective pH range for the treatment of wastewater contaminants.

Theory for Nonlinear Spectroscopy of Vibrational Polaritons.

Molecular polaritons have gained considerable attention due to their potential to control nanoscale molecular processes by harnessing electromagnetic coherence. Although recent experiments with liquid-phase vibrational polaritons have shown great promise for exploiting these effects, significant challenges remain in interpreting their spectroscopic signatures. We develop a quantum-mechanical theory of pump-probe spectroscopy for this class of polaritons based on the quantum Langevin equation and the input-output theory. Comparison with recent experimental data shows good agreement upon consideration of the various vibrational anharmonicities that modulate the signals. Finally, a simple and intuitive interpretation of the data based on an effective mode-coupling theory is provided. Our work provides a solid theoretical framework to elucidate nonlinear optical properties of molecular polaritons as well as to analyze further multidimensional spectroscopy experiments on these systems.

Two-dimensional infrared spectroscopy of vibrational polaritons.

We report experimental 2D infrared (2D IR) spectra of coherent light-matter excitations--molecular vibrational polaritons. The application of advanced 2D IR spectroscopy to vibrational polaritons challenges and advances our understanding in both fields. First, the 2D IR spectra of polaritons differ drastically from free uncoupled excitations and a new interpretation is needed. Second, 2D IR uniquely resolves excitation of hybrid light-matter polaritons and unexpected dark states in a state-selective manner, revealing otherwise hidden interactions between them. Moreover, 2D IR signals highlight the impact of molecular anharmonicities which are applicable to virtually all molecular systems. A quantum-mechanical model is developed which incorporates both nuclear and electrical anharmonicities and provides the basis for interpreting this class of 2D IR spectra. This work lays the foundation for investigating phenomena of nonlinear photonics and chemistry of molecular vibrational polaritons which cannot be probed with traditional linear spectroscopy.

Ultrafast Transmission Modulation and Recovery via Vibrational Strong Coupling.

Strong coupling between vibrational modes and cavity optical modes leads to the formation of vibration-cavity polaritons, separated by the vacuum Rabi splitting. The splitting depends on the square root of the concentration of absorbers confined in the cavity, which has important implications on the response of the coupled system after ultrafast infrared excitation. In this work, we report on solutions of W(CO)6 in hexane with a concentration chosen to access a regime that borders on weak coupling. Under these conditions, large fractions of the W(CO)6 oscillators can be excited, and the anharmonicity of the molecules leads to a commensurate reduction in the Rabi splitting. We report excitation fractions > 0.4, depending on excitation pulse intensity, and show drastic increases in transmission that can be modulated on the picosecond time scale. In comparison to previous experiments, the transient spectra that we observe are much simpler because excited-state transitions lie outside of the transmission spectrum of the cavity, thereby contributing only weakly to the spectra. We find that the Rabi splitting recovers with the characteristic vibrational relaxation lifetime and anisotropy decay of uncoupled W(CO)6, implying that polaritons are not directly involved in the relaxation we observe after the first few ps. The results help corroborate the model that we proposed to describe the results at higher concentrations and show that the ground-state bleach of cavity-coupled molecules has a broad, multisigned spectral response.

Static and Time-Resolved Terahertz Measurements of Photoconductivity in Solution-Deposited Ruthenium Dioxide Nanofilms.

Thin-film ruthenium dioxide (RuO2) is a promising alternative material as a conductive electrode in electronic applications because its rutile crystalline form is metallic and highly conductive. Herein, a solution-deposition multi-layer technique is employed to fabricate ca. 70 ± 20 nm thick films (nanoskins) and terahertz spectroscopy is used to determine their photoconductive properties. Upon calcining at temperatures ranging from 373 K to 773 K, nanoskins undergo a transformation from insulating (localized charge transport) behavior to metallic behavior. Terahertz time-domain spectroscopy (THz-TDS) indicates that nanoskins attain maximum static conductivity when calcined at 673 K (σ = 1030 ± 330 S·cm-1). Picosecond time-resolved Terahertz spectroscopy (TRTS) using 400 nm and 800 nm excitation reveals a transition to metallic behavior when calcined at 523 K. For calcine temperatures less than 523 K, the conductivity increases following photoexcitation (ΔE < 0) while higher calcine temperatures yield films composed of crystalline, rutile RuO2 and the conductivity decreases (ΔE > 0) following photoexcitation.

Quantification of Efficient Plasmonic Hot-Electron Injection in Gold Nanoparticle-TiO2 Films.

Excitation of localized surface plasmons in metal nanostructures generates hot electrons that can be transferred to an adjacent semiconductor, greatly enhancing the potential light-harvesting capabilities of photovoltaic and photocatalytic devices. Typically, the external quantum efficiency of these hot-electron devices is too low for practical applications (<1%), and the physics underlying this low yield remains unclear. Here, we use transient absorption spectroscopy to quantify the efficiency of the initial electron transfer in model systems composed of gold nanoparticles (NPs) fully embedded in TiO2 or Al2O3 films. In independent experiments, we measure free carrier absorption and electron-phonon decay in the model systems and determine that the electron-injection efficiency from the Au NPs to the TiO2 ranges from about 25% to 45%. While much higher than some previous estimates, the measured injection efficiency is within an upper-bound estimate based on a simple approximation for the Au hot-electron energy distribution. These results have important implications for understanding the achievable injection efficiencies of hot-electron plasmonic devices and show that the injection efficiency can be high for Au NPs fully embedded within a semiconductor with dimensions less than the Au electron mean free path.

Plasmonic Aerogels as a Three-Dimensional Nanoscale Platform for Solar Fuel Photocatalysis.

We use plasmonic Au-TiO2 aerogels as a platform in which to marry synthetically thickened particle-particle junctions in TiO2 aerogel networks to Au∥TiO2 interfaces and then investigate their cooperative influence on photocatalytic hydrogen (H2) generation under both broadband (i.e., UV + visible light) and visible-only excitation. In doing so, we elucidate the dual functions that incorporated Au can play as a water reduction cocatalyst and as a plasmonic sensitizer. We also photodeposit non-plasmonic Pt cocatalyst nanoparticles into our composite aerogels in order to leverage the catalytic water-reducing abilities of Pt. This Au-TiO2/Pt arrangement in three dimensions effectively utilizes conduction-band electrons injected into the TiO2 aerogel network upon exciting the Au SPR at the Au∥TiO2 interface. The extensive nanostructured high surface-area oxide network in the aerogel provides a matrix that spatially separates yet electrochemically connects plasmonic nanoparticle sensitizers and metal nanoparticle catalysts, further enhancing solar-fuels photochemistry. We compare the photocatalytic rates of H2 generation with and without Pt cocatalysts added to Au-TiO2 aerogels and demonstrate electrochemical linkage of the SPR-generated carriers at the Au∥TiO2 interfaces to downfield Pt nanoparticle cocatalysts. Finally, we investigate visible light-stimulated generation of conduction band electrons in Au-TiO2 and TiO2 aerogels using ultrafast visible pump/IR probe spectroscopy. Substantially more electrons are produced at Au-TiO2 aerogels due to the incorporated SPR-active Au nanoparticle, whereas the smaller population of electrons generated at Au-free TiO2 aerogels likely originate at shallow traps in the high surface-area mesoporous aerogel.

Transient Optical and Terahertz Spectroscopy of Nanoscale Films of RuO2.

Solution-deposited nanoscale films of RuO2 ("nanoskins") are effective transparent conductors once calcined to 200 °C. Upon heating the nanoskins to higher temperature the nanoskins show increased transmission at 550 nm. Electronic microscopy and X-ray diffraction show that the changes in the optical spectrum are accompanied by the formation of rutile RuO2 nanoparticles. The mechanism for the spectral evolution is clearly observed with ultrafast optical measurements. Following excitation at 400 nm, nanoskins calcined at higher temperatures show increased transmission above 650 nm, consistent with the photobleaching of a surface-plasmon resonance (SPR) band. Calculations based on the optical constants of RuO2 substantiate the presence of SPR absorption. Sheet resistance and transient terahertz photoconductivity measurements establish that the nanoskins electrically de-wire into separated particles. The plasmonic behavior of the nanoskins has implications their use in a range of optical and electrochemical applications.

Aspect-ratio driven evolution of high-order resonant modes and near-field distributions in localized surface phonon polariton nanostructures.

Polar dielectrics have garnered much attention as an alternative to plasmonic metals in the mid- to long-wave infrared spectral regime due to their low optical losses. As such, nanoscale resonators composed of these materials demonstrate figures of merit beyond those achievable in plasmonic equivalents. However, until now, only low-order, phonon-mediated, localized polariton resonances, known as surface phonon polaritons (SPhPs), have been observed in polar dielectric optical resonators. In the present work, we investigate the excitation of 16 distinct high-order, multipolar, localized surface phonon polariton resonances that are optically excited in rectangular pillars etched into a semi-insulating silicon carbide substrate. By elongating a single pillar axis we are able to significantly modify the far- and near-field properties of localized SPhP resonances, opening the door to realizing narrow-band infrared sources with tailored radiation patterns. Such control of the near-field behavior of resonances can also impact surface enhanced infrared optical sensing, which is mediated by polarization selection rules, as well as the morphology and strength of resonator hot spots. Furthermore, through the careful choice of polar dielectric material, these results can also serve as the guiding principles for the generalized design of optical devices that operate from the mid- to far-infrared.

Atomic-scale photonic hybrids for mid-infrared and terahertz nanophotonics.

The field of nanophotonics focuses on the ability to confine light to nanoscale dimensions, typically much smaller than the wavelength of light. The goal is to develop light-based technologies that are impossible with traditional optics. Subdiffractional confinement can be achieved using either surface plasmon polaritons (SPPs) or surface phonon polaritons (SPhPs). SPPs can provide a gate-tunable, broad-bandwidth response, but suffer from high optical losses; whereas SPhPs offer a relatively low-loss, crystal-dependent optical response, but only over a narrow spectral range, with limited opportunities for active tunability. Here, motivated by the recent results from monolayer graphene and multilayer hexagonal boron nitride heterostructures, we discuss the potential of electromagnetic hybrids--materials incorporating mixtures of SPPs and SPhPs--for overcoming the limitations of the individual polaritons. Furthermore, we also propose a new type of atomic-scale hybrid--the crystalline hybrid--where mixtures of two or more atomic-scale (∼3 nm or less) polar dielectric materials lead to the creation of a new material resulting from hybridized optic phonon behaviour of the constituents, potentially allowing direct control over the dielectric function. These atomic-scale hybrids expand the toolkit of materials for mid-infrared to terahertz nanophotonics and could enable the creation of novel actively tunable, yet low-loss optics at the nanoscale.

Low-loss, extreme subdiffraction photon confinement via silicon carbide localized surface phonon polariton resonators.

Plasmonics provides great promise for nanophotonic applications. However, the high optical losses inherent in metal-based plasmonic systems have limited progress. Thus, it is critical to identify alternative low-loss materials. One alternative is polar dielectrics that support surface phonon polariton (SPhP) modes, where the confinement of infrared light is aided by optical phonons. Using fabricated 6H-silicon carbide nanopillar antenna arrays, we report on the observation of subdiffraction, localized SPhP resonances. They exhibit a dipolar resonance transverse to the nanopillar axis and a monopolar resonance associated with the longitudinal axis dependent upon the SiC substrate. Both exhibit exceptionally narrow linewidths (7-24 cm(-1)), with quality factors of 40-135, which exceed the theoretical limit of plasmonic systems, with extreme subwavelength confinement of (λ(res)3/V(eff))1/3 = 50-200. Under certain conditions, the modes are Raman-active, enabling their study in the visible spectral range. These observations promise to reinvigorate research in SPhP phenomena and their use for nanophotonic applications.

Identification of a Methane Oxidation Intermediate on Solid Oxide Fuel Cell Anode Surfaces with Fourier Transform Infrared Emission.

Fuel interactions on solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) anodes are studied with in situ Fourier transform infrared emission spectroscopy (FTIRES). SOFCs are operated at 800 °C with CH4 as a representative hydrocarbon fuel. IR signatures of gas-phase oxidation products, CO2(g) and CO(g), are observed while cells are under load. A broad feature at 2295 cm(-1) is assigned to CO2 adsorbed on Ni as a CH4 oxidation intermediate during cell operation and while carbon deposits are electrochemically oxidized after CH4 operation. Electrochemical control provides confirmation of the assignment of adsorbed CO2. FTIRES has been demonstrated as a viable technique for the identification of fuel oxidation intermediates and products in working SOFCs, allowing for the elucidation of the mechanisms of fuel chemistry.